[00:00:00] Speaker A: Welcome to Vote Chicago, an independent, nonpartisan civic guide built for one purpose. To help Chicago voters make a more informed decision in the 2027 mayoral election. Diving deep into the key issues facing Chicago today with experts that know them best and sitting down with the candidates running for mayor to have direct, structured conversations about their plans for Chicago.
Everything here is designed to make sure you're ready at the ballot box. I'm Jesse Tadoski
[00:00:30] Speaker B: and and I'm Ashley Hartman and we're looking forward to helping you get the information you need to Vote Chicago.
This program does not endorse any candidate and is not affiliated with any campaign, political party, government agency or organization. All candidates we interview have been invited to participate under a standardized format. The views expressed by candidates are solely their own and this program does not verify their accuracy. This is for informational purposes only. Please see our show notes for the full disclaimer.
Last episode we talked about what makes a good mayor, including the history, the skills, the instincts and the judgment it takes to run a city this complex.
But today we're flipping the question because before we can evaluate candidates, we need to understand what they're walking into and need to grapple with on day one.
What are the real challenges facing Chicago right now?
What's at stake?
What do voters need to understand beyond campaign slogans?
Because during elections you'll hear a lot of promises, but much less about the systems, the constraints and the trade offs behind them.
We've organized the key challenges into five Public safety, economic development and jobs, Education, Housing and the budget.
This episode covers the first four, and the budget gets its own episode because honestly, it deserves one as it touches everything else.
Here's how it's going to work. For each issue, we brought in an expert, someone who works on these problems every day, not someone here to push a candidate or a policy agenda.
They're here to help us understand the system, how it works, what's broken, and what's actually possible.
Each expert will give us a short overview and then I'll ask them a set of questions. You'll notice the questions follow a similar framework across the issues because we think those frames are actually the most useful ones for evaluating what you'll hear from candidates on the campaign trail.
Our goal today is simple. Give you a clearer lens on what matters and what's realistic, because promises are easy, but governing is hard.
Let's get into it.
I'm going to start with one of the most visible and debated issues in Chicago, public safety. We're going to start with public safety because For a lot of Chicagoans, it's the first and most salient thing that comes to mind when they think about what's wrong with this city. And it's probably the issue that gets the most airtime in every election.
2025 was actually a historic year.
The fewest homicides since the 1960s, down nearly 30% from the year before.
But violent crime here still runs well above comparable cities. And that burden falls overwhelmingly on communities on the south and west sides.
The next mayor is going to inherit both the progress and the remaining challenges.
To help us make sense of it all, I am thrilled to welcome Rosanna Ander. Rosanna is the founding Executive director of the University of Chicago Crime Lab and Education Lab, one of the most respected research institutions in the country when it comes to using data to improve public safety.
Under her leadership, the crime lab launched the Policing Leadership Academy and the Community Violence Intervention Leadership Academy, first of their kind programs that train police commanders and community violence workers in data driven approaches to reducing violence.
Her colleague Jens Ludwig just published a book called Unforgiving Places that's getting a ton of attention.
It challenges a lot of what we think we know about why gun violence happens and what it actually takes to stop it. If you haven't read it, it's well worth your time. Rosanna, welcome to the podcast. Thank
[00:04:23] Speaker C: you.
[00:04:23] Speaker B: I'd love for you to set the stage. Please walk us through where things stand with public safety right now.
[00:04:29] Speaker C: Well, you hit the good news, which is we really have seen some progress in the last couple of years, but I think it's really important that we not spike the football. As you mentioned, we really are not in a comparable place compared to our, what I would argue our most important peer cities, Los Angeles and New York, we're orders of magnitude higher in terms of our serious violent crime.
And so I think really figuring out how we can at the city level, pull the levers that will drive the kind of progress so that we are in the same ballpark as our peer cities of Los Angeles and New York, which would require decreasing our serious violence.
Right now, we're probably five times as high as New York City and about two to three times as high as Los Angeles. So that just gives you a sense of the work still ahead, despite the important progress. And I think one thing that most people don't realize is yes, L.A. and New York are very different cities than Chicago. But going back to the early 1900s, Chicago, Louisiana and New York had almost identical homicide rates. The most kind of important part of the violent crime problem the most socially costly, harmful piece of it. With two exceptions. One is during the Al Capone era, Chicago was an outlier and not in a good way. The other exception is right now, the last decade or decade and a half, I would say we've lacked the progress that LA and New York have had. New York dropped its homicide rate from its peak in the early 90s by about literally 90% and LA has dropped it by about 80%. We've sort of dropped it by 50%. We've had some big, big spikes up, some encouraging spikes down, but the long term trend is not what we need it to be.
[00:06:08] Speaker B: That is really important at salient to think about how we compare to these peer cities and like 2 to 5x those are huge numbers. They're not insignificant. And while we're kind of on that topic of data, I do want to talk about. So I know you ground everything you do in data. That's what the crime lab is incredible at. If voters could just pick one metric to track over the next mayoral term, one number that would tell you, okay, this mayor is actually moving the needle. What would that be and why?
[00:06:38] Speaker C: Well, I appreciate you highlighting how data driven we are. We really do try to be empirical, data driven and non ideological.
But I want to remind us and everyone who's listening, those are numbers, but those are also people. It is lives that are being destroyed when we are tracking the number of violent crime incidents. So I would argue the most important metric to track, if we were just going to narrow it down to one, it would be shooting incidents per capita. So adjusted for the size of our population. So then you can do an apples to apples comparison of our peer cities.
And it really is the shooting incidents. As I said, gun violence does the lion's share of the harm or the cost of crime in, in the world, in our city and in our country.
And so we have lost. The population of Chicago has decreased by about a million people since the 1950s. One of the major drivers of that population loss is public safety. It's violent crime, it's gun violence. And so we've lost a million people either by people choosing to move out. And you can see that we have neighborhoods that have been hollowed out because of gun violence on the south and west sides. But it's also people choosing not to move into our cities. So all of the challenges that our city faces would be much easier to solve if we had a million more people contributing to our tax base. So I think the shooting incidents are probably the most per capita, are the Most important single metric.
[00:08:05] Speaker B: And thank you so much for kind of teasing out that we need to think about the human impact, not just the number behind that, because the number can hide, you know, what impact it's having on our city, both personally and, you know, more globally.
So we've seen real progress in 2025, which you've highlighted. You've also highlighted that there's a sense that things, you know, still don't feel safe. And I think even in a lot of neighborhoods, not only on the south and west side, we feel like the safety, you know, isn't quite there as it was a few years ago. You know what, why is this issue still so urgent? What's going on? And, you know, how should we think about that?
[00:08:41] Speaker C: Yeah. You know, again, gun violence sits upstream of every other challenge our city faces. Gun violence has a huge ripple effect. It has an impact on students, ability to learn in school. It has an impact on property values. It has an impact on, you know, whether people choose to move into the city. So I think there, while there's been progress made, I think there are some very important headwinds that we need to take into consideration and not assume that we're just going to continue without really intentional effort to see the declines continue. So the headwinds are our city and state are flat broke.
The federal government, I think, is unlikely to be coming in with significant new resources, as they did post pandemic.
And I think another even kind of less, I think, appreciated challenge is we are seeing some of the data work that we've done recently. We've uncovered the fact that while overall homicides are going down, and that is the really good news, when there is a shooting incident, it is much more likely to be fatal. And that's, I think, because of some of the new features of firearms. We are seeing things like machine gun conversion devices being recovered on guns. So that changes a regular handgun into a fully automatic machine gun, which means more rounds are fired much more quickly. We're seeing many more guns recovered with high capacity magazines. So the lethality rate is increasing. So I think all of those sort of challenges of budget challenges and new and more lethal kind of firepower on the streets make it really important that we not just sort of stand back and hope that the positive trend of decrease continues. And we need to be able to do this in a way that recognizes we're not going to have an infusion of lots of new resources. So I think it's urgent because right now companies can locate and people can, you know, we're in such a global economy, and the world has changed so dramatically. And I think three of the things that really determine the population growth and economic growth of a city. One is weather, what's a big factor. The other is education levels of the population. And the third is public safety. Weather's not one we can probably do a lot about, but the other two are important. But we cannot again just hope that the positive trends continue.
It is urgent, and I think it really. The stakes are very high right now.
[00:11:11] Speaker B: Yeah. Which brings us to this election. And every mayor is certainly going to promise to make Chicago safer. It's kind of the, you know, campaign promise that you can count on. But when you actually look at the levers available, what do you think the mayor realistically controls versus where that leverage is really overstated. And people, I'm sure, commonly misunderstand what controls the mayor has.
[00:11:35] Speaker C: So I'm going to offer sort of two things. One that is probably very obvious, and the other one that I think is underappreciated in terms of levers that the mayor has. One is policing. I think it's the thing that gets the most attention. We talk about it. When we talk about public safety, policing becomes synonymous. I think that is obviously a really important lever. It's a $2 billion city agency.
So I think really focusing on making sure that we have quality leadership, that the police department's being data driven, that it's not being sort of managed by kind of alderman or politics, but really having a competent leader. And just sort of one example is we've had, I think, five or six superintendents over a very short period of time. Every time a new superintendent comes in, not only do we have a new kind of CEO of the police department, we have an entirely new C suite. Can you imagine trying to run a $2 billion company when every couple of years you have dramatic leadership change? So I think really thinking about the leadership of the police department and also ensuring that the police department can be really data driven, that's sort of an obvious one. I think the bigger lever, in some ways and in some ways, the more important lever that isn't really thought of as a public safety lever is our $9 billion school system.
So, you know, there's just reams and reams of very strong evidence showing that schooling attainment is massively protective against crime involvement as both victims and as perpetrators. And yet, while we've made progress in many ways as a city, in terms of increasing our graduation rate, there are probably right now at least 25,000 school age kids walking around Chicago who are no longer attending school and yet don't have a high school diploma. And we need to really focus that system in a way that can do a lot of prevention work that can really attain, help young people attain the educations they need to be productive members of society. And I think there's, there's some real missed opportunities with the public school system. So I would say that's an important lever. And we have lots of ideas and even lots of evidence about what can be done to really help the young people who are not being well served by the current way we do public education.
[00:13:52] Speaker B: That's really important to kind of tease out just the operations of a department and the leadership from just kind of thinking about policing more broadly. Are there areas where you think that we think the mayor has more control than they actually do?
[00:14:07] Speaker C: Yeah, I mean, I think recognizing that, you know, cities can't run deficits, and I think it's really, you know, there are a lot of pieces of the broader public safety ecosystem that are run by the county or by the state. And it's also a place where the federal government could play an important role. I'm just not optimistic that they will. But the court system, the jails, all of that is outside of the city's control. So I do think, making sure that we have a leader who understands how to be collaborative, how to work together, how to, you know, I think we've had so many examples of finger pointing and the sort of shifting the blame as opposed to saying, how do we work together to create a systematic approach to our violent crime problem?
And that means working with other parts of government that aren't under the control of the mayor.
[00:15:00] Speaker B: There's no policy in this space that doesn't involve hard choices. You know, what are the tradeoffs the next mayor is going to have to confront when they come into office that we probably won't hear about on the campaign trail. But we should keep in mind.
[00:15:11] Speaker C: I just think it's good to remember there are actually no free lunches. There are going to. We either pay now or we pay later. We make the hard choices now or we pay the price down the line, whether it's in terms of population loss, whether it's in terms of, you know, increased violent crime rates. If we don't make hard choices around how to run these public sector agencies. And so I think recognizing that there are going to be hard choices, if this mayor doesn't make them, they're just kicking the can down the road because we will Pay the price down the line.
[00:15:44] Speaker B: And when you're listening to a candidate talk about public safety, what makes you think they actually understand the issue versus just kind of using rhetoric or impressive sounding language, you know, what should we listen for as voters to give us confidence that this mayoral candidate is actually on top of this issue?
[00:16:02] Speaker C: I think recognizing that public safety is such a multifaceted challenge, and I think offering very simple solutions that cost a lot of money mean that I think there's a lot of magical thinking going on. I think someone who really understands the importance of operations, someone who's willing to surround themselves by people who really have deep expertise. And I think really so much of the effectiveness of government comes down to operations and having the humility to surround yourself by people who maybe don't always agree with you on things, but are really strong, strong leaders in their space. And so when I hear mayors make sweeping promises about how quickly they can solve violent crime or the silver bullet to solving violent crime, it makes me very skeptical.
[00:16:59] Speaker B: I think operations is probably, if I could guess, going to be a theme in a lot of the conversations today around these key issues.
So my last question is a personal one. In your opinion, outside public safety, what makes a good mayor?
[00:17:12] Speaker C: Again, I think someone who has the humility to know that they don't have all the answers that is willing to surround themselves with people who are really, really strong leaders and competent in their area and someone who's willing to listen and not sort of offer, you know, easy answers to things.
So, you know, I'll be listening very closely to what they're saying and who they're surrounding themselves with. Bye,
[00:17:40] Speaker B: Rosanna, thank you so much for your insights. I'm definitely leaving this conversation with a much sharper and more nuanced picture of the issue, both on the data side and the human side. So I now have this better set of questions to ask candidates, which is really helpful and I think it will be helpful to our listeners.
So appreciate your being here.
[00:17:58] Speaker C: Thank you so much.
[00:17:59] Speaker B: And public safety and economic opportunity are deeply connected. Research shows that when communities have jobs, when young people have pathways, violence goes down. So it's only natural that our next issue will be economic development and jobs. Chicago is the third largest city in the country.
Fifteen Fortune 500 companies, world class universities, one of the busiest airports on the planet, and a massive labor force.
By every measure, we should be a dominant economic engine.
And yet job growth here has consistently lagged the national average.
Major corporate headquarters have left, including Boeing, Caterpillar, Citadel and Tyson. And the Economic opportunity that does exist is just unequal.
Population decline continues to be a drag on consumer demand and tax revenue.
The next mayor has to figure out how to change that trajectory and make hard choices about where to invest, how to compete, and how to make sure growth isn't just concentrated in a handful of zip codes. To help us think through what's at stake, I'm so excited to have Michael Fosnacht here, who is a prominent business executive and marketing and strategic thought leader in Chicago. Michael was previously the CEO of World Business Chicago, whose core focus is growing the city's industry sectors, as well as Chief Marketing Officer for Chicago under Lori Lightfoot. He's now Chief Growth Officer and president of Chicagoland at Clayco. Michael, welcome to the podcast.
I can't think of a better person for this topic, so I'd love to start and have you just set the stage and give us the big picture, what's going on with Chicago's economy?
[00:19:37] Speaker D: So, first of all, thank you, Ashley, for having me here. It's great you're doing this. I think it's important to educate the public in Chicago across all neighborhoods what's going on and what's important in the upcoming election and just overall how Chicago is doing.
I think the product picture in Chicago is mixed. I think we have some great things going on. Some of the major economic development projects, Mohai Airport, Quantum Park, Project 1901 78, are going really well. After having been stagnant for many years, we see a lot of momentum.
On the other hand, we still haven't come back like in downtown to where we are pre Covid. If you look at New York, they are above foot traffic. In downtown New York, we are still 30, 35% below pre Covid.
We still haven't addressed the big quality of life delta between the different neighborhoods.
And I think we still haven't really found the narrative about Chicago. Why is it such a phenomenal place to start a business, build your career, start a family?
So a lot of good things happening, but also a lot of challenges.
[00:20:46] Speaker B: Yeah, well, if one thing you are really good at is the narrative building, if anyone doesn't know, Michael is a mini LinkedIn influencer, so you should all follow him.
[00:20:54] Speaker D: I call myself a micro micro regional LinkedIn influencer. That's correct.
[00:20:58] Speaker B: A little bit more than that.
So if you had to point to one metric that best captures Chicago's economic challenge today, what would it be and what does it tell us?
[00:21:07] Speaker D: So if you allow me, I give two metrics. One is very simple GDP GDP is the best measure for just overall economic growth. Over the last 10 years, we always have been performed below the national average. We should be at least at national GDP growth, hopefully above. So that's a simple matrix. We can measure every month
[00:21:27] Speaker B: how far below the national average, just to tease that out for listeners
[00:21:30] Speaker D: normally always close to a percentage point.
So let's say if the nation grows by 3%, we maybe grow by 2%. And to be fair, it's not just a city. We always look at the data for the metro area because I think it's false to just look at the city as an economic engine. It's Chicagoland, the metro area.
So one, I think is gdp. The second, what I call the quality of life Delta data.
If we look at the key quality of life data across neighborhoods, there's a massive delta. If you have life expectancies up to 20 years between the best zip code and the worst zip code in Chicago, unemployment, unemployment. Linkin park is 2, 2.5% for young black men in Inglewood over 30.
If you look at health indicators, safety, everything across the city has a massive quality of life delta. So I think we need to look at both economic growth, but economic growth alone does not tell the whole story. We need to look as well, is the economic growth enabling to close that quality of life delta across all of our neighborhoods?
[00:22:38] Speaker B: That's where you kind of get into these problems with averages. Right? The averages might look okay or maybe just a little bit below. When you say 1%, it doesn't sound like a huge percentage, but when you look at that delta, it really compounds.
So really, really important to kind of tease out.
So some of these trends like lagging growth or corporate departures and population loss, they've been kind of building over time. There's not just a, you know, didn't just happen overnight. Why do you feel like this is so urgent now? What's happening now that makes this so important to pay attention to?
[00:23:10] Speaker D: I think it's urgent because I think what we're doing right now will set up the city and region for the next 5, 10, 20 years.
As you know, the governor is making a push on Quantum. That's an investment in a strategic bet that I'm fully supportive of that will bear positive impact 10 or 20 years down the road. So things we decide right now, the city budget, every city budget, every year, yes, is a budget for this fiscal year. But it's also, how does it set it on trajectory to have better financial discipline or not?
If you look at investment, education, so Everything do right now is not just about this year at this moment. It is about the future. And I think for too long we have sometimes not made the hard decisions.
I think we have not been as pro growth as we should be. I think we have lost our ambition to think big to big projects. Chicago has always been a city of builders. I think we lost it over the last couple years.
So all these things are right now kind of a focal point.
And I do believe that the technology changes with AI will further impact how people live and work and how they create wealth.
So this is.
We have a lot of issues and challenges I think that we need to address right now.
[00:24:28] Speaker B: Yeah, you're implicitly teasing out the point that all the problems we're seeing now were really from 10 years ago, a decade ago. So any decisions we make now are going to continue to compound over time. So we need to really think about kind of always, every year think about the future, not just that year.
[00:24:44] Speaker D: Yeah. And I think sometimes the challenge is if you're an elected official, if you only have one term, you cannot probably create enough change. You probably need two or three terms.
So I'm still very optimistic if you look at the fundamentals of our city.
But I think we lost a bit of our growth mindset. We cannot cost cut our way to a prosperous great future. We need to grow and be fiscally responsible.
[00:25:13] Speaker B: Yeah, Very important. We'll get into the budget in the next episode. So you're teasing that up nicely.
So the mayor gets a lot of credit and a lot of blame for the economy in Chicago. But realistically, the mayor controls certain levers and doesn't control others. Where do you think the lever, where are the levers that the mayor controls and where are those overstated that we should understand? As a voter,
[00:25:33] Speaker D: I mean, I had the pleasure of working close with Mayor Lightfoot for over four years and has worked with Mayor Johnson for almost a year.
I think a lot of people misunderstand the role of the mayor. The first and most important of the mayor is operational.
You run an organization with 30,000 employees, 20 billion dollar budget. You have to run that organization. You have to put leader in place, you have to make sure the streets are clean, garbage being picked up, that we have a great police chief. So these are not policy. These are not really political topics. These are pure operational leadership roles.
I think second, it is policy.
What are the priorities that we're focusing on fiscally, but also from policy perspective. But that's maybe only 10 or 20%. The last but not least the mayor is what I call, let's say, the chief narrator of the city. You're the chief ambassador, you're the CMO of the city because you represent the city as the face and in interaction with the president of the United States, with business leaders, with community leaders. So I think first, operations, second, policy, and third, you're shaping the narrative of our city. And I think a lot of people mixing up these priorities and focusing so much on policy instead of the pure operations, sound operation of our city.
[00:26:51] Speaker B: Is there a place where the mayor's role you think is overstated? Like kind of from your vantage point in the economy? Like the mayor just doesn't control X, y or Z, but they get the blame or the credit for that?
[00:27:03] Speaker D: Yeah, I think if you look, even public safety, I mean, we have seen a record number in violence reduction, but it's a nationwide trend. We also have benefited from this in Chicago, I think, with a great police chief, Larry Snelling.
What the mayor.
If you look at the history of Chicago, the mayor was always a strong mayor, not structurally, in reality.
And I think this changed. As we all know, City council is now much more active and fighting back and pushing back a lot of topics, but the mayor still has a lot of power.
I do believe if a company make a decision to invest in Chicago, maybe relocate. A call from the mayor, in conversation with the mayor matters. Governor Pritzker has shown that I work with him on the quantum park. His engagement, his leadership, his voice mattered in decisions by executives. So I think you have more informal power than most people even believe and realize.
[00:28:01] Speaker B: That's really helpful to tease out. And I think everyone can agree growing Chicago's economy is a net good. Right. But that involves such real trade offs, and you even pointed to these disparities across neighborhoods that we have to really pay attention to. What are the hardest calls an ex mayor is going to have to make in this election? Because there are some real constraints and trade offs that we have to pay attention to.
[00:28:22] Speaker D: I think the hardest trade off is, as we all know, campaigning is very different from governing. And whoever is getting elected or reelected, you probably have less friends in government than campaigning.
I think there's a lot of hard decision, fiscal decisions. I think we have to reduce the city budget. We grew from a $10 billion budget in 2019 to like a $17 billion budget just last year.
We have to look at the school infrastructure and the cost structure, what works and what doesn't work. And we have to even look at the police department because some of the largest cost items in our city.
So I think that the toughest one is to making hard decisions and maybe making people that support you in the campaign, having the opposition against some of decision. You have to be really independent. You have to put the good of the city ahead of your own, maybe personal reelection chances and having a strong coalition of supporters.
[00:29:23] Speaker B: And that's where that informal role you were talking about really comes into play.
So economic development is a place where candidates just throw around a lot of impressive sounding language, a lot of promises. How do you separate kind of what's real versus just rhetoric?
[00:29:39] Speaker D: For me, a simple measure is whenever I look at a candidate, an elected official, my test is if I bring this person to a meeting with the CEO and they're pitching the CEO something, investing $100 million in your office, relocating, expanding, is this elected official helping me to persuade the CEO?
Is the elected official neutral or is the elected official a negative in the meeting? And that's simple. So I will always support someone who can help me or anyone else.
Closing a deal, getting investment, city of Chicago. That's for me a very simple filter.
[00:30:18] Speaker B: So pay attention to whether you want them kind of in the room with you.
[00:30:21] Speaker D: Yes. If you don't want them in the room because you don't think they will help you, you might not be the right person to vote for.
[00:30:27] Speaker B: That's a good rubric which to evaluate in your opinion, just stepping back from economic development, what makes a good mayor?
[00:30:36] Speaker D: I think a good mayor understands that building an amazing team and putting the right people in the leadership positions. I remember when Mayor Lifelaw got elected, you have to make more than 500 leadership positions, Sister agencies, boards in your own mayor's office team. So you make a lot of personnel decisions.
And it's not, as we all know, who have led organizations. It's not easy to find the right people. So I think it's very important for the mayor to build a strong team, not just within the mayor's office, but in all agencies. We saw it with Larry Snelling, who was a great choice, we said with the airport commissioner, who's doing a phenomenal job now with the new D case commissioner with Kenya Marriott. So these decisions matter because you're just at the top of the spear of 30,000 people who all influence our lives.
I think second is you have to have a growth mindset. You have to be really making big bets, focusing. How can I grow economy, the population, our brand, value, everything.
And last but not least, I think you need to understand government.
I'm very hesitant to support elected officials who don't understand government.
I ran a business for most of my life when I worked in a government. It's very different. You cannot run government like running a business if you don't understand this. It's very difficult to transfer this expertise.
Same thing if you never worked within government. It's tough to understand the complexity of government.
[00:32:05] Speaker B: That's incredibly helpful. And you kind of broke it down in such a clear, concise way.
So that was my last question. Michael, I cannot thank you enough for being here. It was fantastic to hear your insights. And I think the economy in Chicago is so nuanced and you really kind of teased out what we should be looking for as voters. So cannot thank you enough for being.
[00:32:25] Speaker D: Thank you for having me, Ashley. My pleasure.
[00:32:26] Speaker B: So economic outcomes and education outcomes are fundamentally linked. Whether a young person in Chicago gets a quality education has enormous amount to do with their economic future and with the city's future.
So with that, I want to turn to our next issue, which is education.
Chicago Public Schools is one of the largest school districts in the country, serving over 300,000 students across the across more than 500 schools.
There's good news in that graduation rates are up and college enrollment is outpacing the national average.
But dig a little deeper and the picture gets a bit complicated.
Only about 40% of CPS elementary students are meeting proficiency benchmarks in reading and math.
And there are also significant disparities across demographics that don't get talked about nearly enough.
The mayor has enormous influence over educational priorities, the budget and the relationship with the teachers union to help us understand education in Chicago. I am thrilled to be joined by Janice Jackson, a nationally recognized education leader. Janice is a former CEO of Chicago Public Schools, where she managed a $7 billion budget and oversaw some of the strongest gains in graduation and achievement in district history.
She went on to lead hope Chicago, which provides debt free college pathways for CPS students and their families. And she's now executive director of the education and Society program at the Aspen Institute, one of the most respected policy institutions in the country.
If anyone has seen the system from the inside and out, it's Janice. So, Janice, welcome to Chicago votes. Thank you. So excited to have you. I'd love for you to and just give us an honest picture of where education in Chicago stands today.
[00:34:13] Speaker E: Yeah. Well, first, thank you for having me. And wow. I spend a lot of time, as you can imagine, thinking about cps, even though I try to promise myself that I'm going to step back. But education is near and Dear to my heart. And so I keep coming back to what's happening in our city because the education system, in my opinion, is one of the most important entities in this city.
And there's a lot going on right now. I think the first thing I would say is that there is a lot of instability in our system right now. And this is a large system which is accustomed to that level of instability. But I would say this is far greater than anything we've ever seen save the pandemic, which was a destabilizing event for everybody. When I think about the biggest challenges, I think about a few things. One, enrollment continues to be the biggest. I don't want to be dramatic and say existential threat for the district, because I think the district will always exist. But I do believe that the declining, the sharp decline in enrollment that's happening in our school system is problematic. It affects funding. It affects the way schools are organized. It affects the experience that students have. For example, when students are in smaller high schools, they don't get the full complement of courses and opportunities that students get when there's a healthy enrollment. So that's number one.
I think the second thing, and you hit on this in the introduction, is student performance, which is always where I want to go and not because I want to put the onus on students. I actually think that's the wrong framing. But I think how our students perform tells us a lot about what is happening in the system and gives us some direction, or should give us some direction on what we're paying attention to. So when I look at student performance, the first thing that comes up, it's opaque. There used to be a higher level of transparency around how students were performing in cps. We haven't seen a school accountability policy and data specific to schools that's clear that parents can understand in years. And I think that's problematic. We do see those outcomes like graduation rates and college enrollment or end of the year test data. But there used to be far more visibility into how schools were performing. And I think that visibility allowed for parents to make choices about where they wanted their school, their children to go to school. And it also allowed schools to make better strategic decisions, choices about how to improve.
The last thing I'll say related to this and this transitions to probably one of the biggest challenges in the district is we also had better connectivity, in my opinion, with parents, meaning, like the local school councils had way more power than I think they have today. And the governance model for the school system has changed drastically.
We now have A hybrid school board, soon to be a fully elected school board in about a year. And that is going to be exciting for a lot of people because a lot of people do believe that we should have a democratically elected school board. What I worry about is if the new school board will operate and prioritize student achievement the way past school boards have.
So far, what I've seen through this governance model is still a lot of attention to challenges, adult challenges. I haven't seen very many presentations on how students are performing the strategy that the district is employing. And so I think those are probably the biggest issues. The last issue, which is probably, probably should have been first, is funding for our schools. The cost of educating kids will continue to go up as it does everywhere, but we don't have a lot of new revenue sources, and so people aren't spending enough time, in my opinion, talking about that. I think it's easy to get distracted by the outcomes and some of the drama around employment with the CEO and other things that seem to dominate the headlines. But the reality is our school, our schools are underfunded. And when new funding comes in, it tends to go straight to salaries and adults, and it's not getting the students to really enhance their experiences. And I think that voters, parents, anybody who cares about our city should be asking more questions about that and should be paying attention to how our schools get funded and how we're spending that money.
[00:38:22] Speaker B: That was an incredibly helpful lay of the land on education and so many challenges that we have to face.
You pointed to a lot of indicators that are showing you that there are a lot of challenges, and there's so many ways to measure kind of CPS health. If you had to pick one metric that tells you the most about how our school system is actually doing, what would it be and what do you think it reveals?
[00:38:47] Speaker E: I think you can look at data on how the school is doing and you hit on one like graduation rates. And those things matter a lot. But I think the best indicator is the employment rate for young people in our city between 18 and 24. A lot of the work that I'm doing now at the Aspen Institute is focused on young people at that critical time in their career they are getting ready to launch, and what they do between 18 and 24 really sets up the rest of their life. If I had to pick one indicator that everyone should be paying attention to in the city, it is how many children between 18 and 24 are unemployed and not in school. The reality is that number is almost 50% for African American students drops down to 25% for Latino students and about 18% for their white counterparts. In some communities in the city, that number is 80%.
So if we're really serious about the city being healthy, and we know that the school system contributes to that, are students able to find gainful employment that supports them and eventually a family when they complete school? And that is not just the school system's challenge and problem.
I think the business community, and you've seen me work with the business community on projects like Hope Chicago. I think they have just as much responsibility around those metrics. What can we do to make sure that we are hiring more people who are residents in this city? Because until we satisfy or address that challenge, our city is never gonna be as healthy and as vibrant for everybody as we want it to be.
[00:40:24] Speaker B: Yeah, I love that. Because it's not enough to just say, okay, you graduated. Yeah, right. Like, you check the box. But, like, what do you. Are you actually employed? Are you actually, you know, keeping yourself, you know, improving over time is so important.
[00:40:38] Speaker E: And I think the improvements are important, but like you said, you got to go two layers down. And when you look at those disparities, they tell us something about what we value in this city. They tell us something about the investments that are being made or not being made. And so that, to me, is one of the most important things. And the mayor does play a big role in setting the vision for that. The mayor does have the bully pulpit to bring the business community to the table, to tell the school system what they should be doing and working on and prioritizing what. We need that type of leadership. We need that connectivity between government and the private sector if we really want to help more students and families thrive.
[00:41:16] Speaker B: And we can't change what we don't actually measure and pay attention
[00:41:19] Speaker E: to. Exactly.
[00:41:21] Speaker B: Why is this so urgent now? You know, is there something that is what's changed over the last few years that really it's come to a head?
[00:41:28] Speaker E: Well, I don't know if it's more urgent. And you're speaking to somebody who. I feel like I'm always, like, at the top of a mountain screaming about something related to education. And so I wish more people focused on education and the outcomes. And that's why, you know, the work I'm doing at Aspen is exciting, because we're trying to do that at a national level. I think that we don't speak about education policy as much as we used to, and I think our country is set back as a result of that. And we see a lot of that showing up here in the city.
What's most urgent right now to I think the average person paying attention to this is a few things. One, in this post pandemic environment, things are just very different.
The way we work and show up is different.
The jobs and opportunities have changed, the way the skills you need in order to have access have changed. And I don't know that our schooling and the opportunities that students are getting through training or education have kept up with that. Then you layer on AI, which everybody is talking about AI, and everybody's also sick of AI at the same time. But the reality is it's here and it is a disruptive factor when you think about, you know, what employers will want from young graduates either from high school or college or career program in the coming years. And I think that when you see all of these forces coming together and then we have trouble articulating what the plan is for our students and young people, that to me, should give us all concern. And like, as I sit here today, that's the thing I'm most concerned about. There are things I can look at and say, hey, this data doesn't look great or this disparity, but I'm really future facing and looking ahead. And I am worried about our children being prepared for the economy that is emerging.
[00:43:12] Speaker B: And that's where, as you were pointing to, employment rate is more important. Right. Than graduation rate. You can graduate. If you don't actually have gainful employment, you're not prepared for it. We're
[00:43:20] Speaker E: not prepared.
[00:43:21] Speaker B: Yeah. That's incredibly valuable.
So the mayor in Chicago has much more direct influence over public education than probably any other major city.
You can correct me if I'm wrong, but there's often confusion about governance. You know, what role does the mayor actually play versus CPS leadership or the state?
[00:43:40] Speaker E: Yeah, well, a couple things I will say, and this may change, it remains to be seen, once a fully elected board is in place. But the mayor. Let me stop this. Sorry. Is this messing up? Don't know. That's fine. Oh, okay. I'm sorry. It's distracting me. All right, I'll go back.
[00:43:57] Speaker B: I can ask you the question. Yeah.
So the mayor in Chicago has more direct influence than many other mayors in major public cities.
But there's often confusion about governance. You know, what role does the mayor play in education in Chicago versus CPS leadership and then the state?
[00:44:14] Speaker E: Yeah, the mayor is in charge of education in the city of Chicago. Still today, even with a hybrid board, we should be clear about that the mayor selects the majority of the board members, including the board chair. Even in our former system, when they selected everybody, there's still kind of this trinity, if you will, the school system, the board and the mayor's office that has to work together in order for this to be successful. Right now, the mayor controls all of that. If we are being quite honest, I think it is going to be interesting to see how things change when we have a fully elected school board and and if individuals will have a level of autonomy to make decisions.
As a person who, you know, studies politics and has been around for a long time, I'm less optimistic maybe than the average person on this because I think we've already seen kind of camps emerge between candidates supported by the teachers union, for example, and candidates supported by the business community kind of being pitted against each other. And if we look at other large urban school districts that have elected school boards, you see some version of that. But if I would just explain into parents how we're organized. The CEO basically is responsible for administering and running the district every single day. So that includes policy, that includes day to day operations, that includes being the spokesperson for the district and obviously creating the budget for the district.
Now, the CEO does not get to determine the budget because that's determined based on school enrollment, taxes and a bunch of other things. And that's where the role of city and state come into play because CPS cannot operate without additional resources from the state, but also from the city. And one of the things that I have seen over time since the Emanuel administration is a reduction in the amount of support via dollars from the city to support Chicago Public Schools. All while the cost of educating kids is going up in our city. As I've explained before, that to me is something that the next mayor has to pay attention to. They have to look at what ways can the city help support the district beyond what's currently happening today. I would also say at the state level we have a good system in that we have evidence based funding formula which is unique to Illinois and only a few other states. When I zoom out and look at the national level, it comes up a lot. And I think Illinois is ahead in how it does fund schools. Now this is a newer phenomenon, it's not even 10 years old, but I also know that we need more money and more funding into that pot.
School districts that are furthest from adequacy get more money each year, but it's just not enough to keep up with the rising cost. And so the role that the state typically plays is that the district has to engage the state in order to get funding to support the district.
Oftentimes in Chicago. And I'm speaking how I think some of our state legislators would speak if they were sitting here. We come back and ask for more because we need it. And the state usually has resources that we can go to. I think as their budget becomes more complicated, as they're trying to stave off changes and things that are happening at the federal level and backfield, because those resources are going away, there are fewer and fewer options for CPS leadership to go to in order to fund the district. And so that to me means that the CEO, the mayor and the board in the next few years are going to have to start making really tough decisions about how the district is currently organized. And it goes back to what I started with, which is the enrollment piece. We have fewer students in this district than we had 10 or 20 years ago, yet we're spending more money to educate them.
Some parts of that makes sense because of inflation and costs go up, but some of that is self inflicted by not really taking a step back and having a true vision for this city that looks at enrollment, that looks at consolidations. And some people won't like that. I said that. But I push back on that. Because what I would pair with any conversation around enrollment management is new schools. We haven't built a single new school in the past two administrations. That's a problem to me. And when I think about it, I think about schools on the south and the west side haven't had new buildings in decades.
How can we seriously say we're serious about improving outcomes for students, especially students furthest from opportunity, when we're not even investing in the very facilities that they wake up and go in every single day to make them feel like the scholars we want all of them to be. And so there's a lot of to that. And it requires all these entities to work together. But what I will say is first someone has to be the adult in the room here in Chicago, usually that's the mayor, to make sure that the city, the district and the board are working together and have a vision for what our students deserve in the schools. And that is to me, what I'll be looking for when I look to see who should be running the city.
[00:49:22] Speaker B: And you're starting to kind of get into this. But education is full of tensions.
We've got equity and choice. We've got fiscal reality and resource allocation versus what students actually need. We have short term politics and Long term outcomes, what are the trade offs the next mayor is going to have to confront that you don't usually hear discussed on the campaign trail.
[00:49:43] Speaker E: Oh, on the campaign trail. Well, I think they're some of the same things, but maybe in different forms given where we are today.
One like we talked about, financing and funding schools will continue to be a big issue. I would really be listening to hear who has a real plan for addressing this, because anybody that walks into that role, either role, the board chair, the CEO or the mayor's office, has to have a true understanding of how school funding and finance works and have a real plan to address a challenge that I think continues to be kicked down the road. And when you kick something like this down the road, the students who I care the most about, those are usually those kids on the south, southwest and west sides of Chicago. They end up getting the short end of the stick. They end up in schools that are woefully underfunded. They end up in schools without the full complement of courses, classes and extracurricular while we're like debating taxes and other stuff at the top. So that's number one. I think the other thing that we have to talk about is school choice at a macro level in the city.
I am a proponent of school choice. I believe in it, but I do think, I believe, I believe in it up to a certain point. And there are real pressures happening right now in the school system that again, anybody who's in charge and serious about addressing these issues has to face. Students are going to school in new and different ways. They're opting out of the public school system in rates that we hadn't seen in CPS, you know, over the last 15 or 20 years. They're going to private schools in some cases, but not all. Some of them are going to micro schools, online schooling.
If vouchers come back to the state of Illinois, that'll be another way. So I think that having a real plan and showing parents stability is critically important so that people select the school system as the first choice. When we were leading cps, we had the largest market share the distance district has ever had in this city. Meaning school age children that attended CPS post pandemic, that number is going down. A lot of that started with the pandemic, but I think it accelerated because of all the challenges that we see happening at the top.
[00:51:56] Speaker B: Is there anything that makes you skeptical when you hear kind of campaign promises?
[00:52:00] Speaker E: Well, to be honest, and I'll be listening closely because in the last couple of campaign cycles I was in it. So I feel like, you know, what's on, going, going on or being said because you're there every day and you feel like the messages are being said. But now that I'm outside of that role, you know, I'm going to be listening like any other resident, any other parent, any other taxpayer, and just seeing who has a real plan. I think when I look at the school board position, which is an important one to me, I will not support anybody who hasn't been an educator in that role. That much I've learned, especially under this new structure. I don't think this present hybrid school board has focused enough on academics at all. Like I said, I haven't seen a lot of information about how our students are performing, how we're holding ourselves accountable for better outcomes for kids. And I don't believe you can get there without having somebody who understands education and educators in that role. And so that to me is a race that I'm going to be watching closely. As far as campaign promises, I think people will say what they think they need to say. You only get so much time in a 30 second commercial to make a point. But what I really hope is that when parents think about what their voting issues are, that quality education and real promises for investment in the communities they live in is at the top of the list. Make that the top voting choice and I think we'll get the right candidate.
[00:53:22] Speaker B: Yeah. Education is just such a topic that it's so easy to make these promises and it's very hard to show results in a four year term particularly. Well,
[00:53:31] Speaker E: you need time. You definitely need more time than four years. But I do believe you can make decisions at the outset that set you up to make that. I worry about promises being made and then an administration starts and you don't see a lot of changes. Anybody who has a true vision for transforming our system would make changes immediately because that is how urgent it is right now.
[00:53:56] Speaker B: I agree with you. Yeah. Last question. From your experience leading a major public institution in the city, not necessarily about education, but what do you think makes a good mayor?
[00:54:05] Speaker E: Oh, there are so many things.
Well, first you have to be, you know, this sounds, this is used over and over again, but I think it's important. You do have to be the CEO of the city. And I mean that because it is a major responsibility. You're working with a lot of different people, competing interests, major budgets. And I do think you have to have a strong business acumen or strong team supporting you in order to effectively administer the city. And that to me is a skill set that should be a non negotiable. I know it has been trendy to vote in people who are kind of outside of that. But I think we have to start asking ourselves what do we really need? And it can't just be a charismatic person. It has to be somebody who has that business acumen, in my opinion.
I think the other thing is they have to have a true belief in diversity and, and all. I don't think that that's always the case on one end or the other. And I think the next mayor that I hope the city selects is somebody who has a true vision for bringing this whole city together and is going to be unapologetic about that. Who won't be afraid to talk about dei, who won't be afraid to talk about students or people who are furthest from opportunity in helping them. First, I think we need somebody who's going to be full throated about that. I think we need somebody who's going to speak truth to power at the federal level, no matter who's in charge. So those are things I'm going to be looking for. And I want somebody who cares about children and cares about education whether their kids are in CPS or not or beyond that point. If you don't truly care about young people in the future, I don't believe you're going to lead the city the way it needs to be led because we are at an important inter.
At an important inflection point as a city and, and the next leader is either going to take us to the next level or take us down a road that might not be great for Chicago.
[00:56:00] Speaker B: We agree. So thank you, Janice. This is really a system that touches every family and having the level of clarity about what's going on and the key challenges and the possibilities is exactly what I think every voter needs. So we're genuinely grateful that you're here with us.
[00:56:15] Speaker E: Thank you.
[00:56:16] Speaker B: So we just talked about how education outcomes and economic opportunity are intertwined.
There's a third piece of that puzzle that shapes everything where people can afford to live. Because if families can't find stable, affordable housing, everything else gets harder. That brings us to our fourth housing.
Chicago has always had a reputation for being affordable, at least compared to coastal cities.
But that's changing.
Housing prices are up 23% since 2019.
Inventory is down more than 50%. And Chicago just posted the biggest rent increase of any major apartment market in the country.
Nearly half of Chicago households are now spending more than 30% of their income on housing. And the neighborhoods that need investment, most south, west and southeast sides are getting the least of it.
All that lands in the lap of the mayor.
Housing is one of the issues where City hall has real tools like zoning, permitting, tax incentives, affordable housing funds.
How the next mayor chooses to use those tools or doesn't will shape the city for a generation.
Our guest is Marisa Novara, VP of Community impact at the Chicago Community Trust and former commissioner of the Chicago Department of Housing.
As housing commissioner, Marisa led the passage of nine pieces of of housing legislation in four years, completed the country's first racial equity impact assessment of low income housing tax credits, and directed more than $1.5 billion in resources toward affordable housing.
Before joining the city, she was vice president at the Metropolitan Planning Council, where she led the groundbreaking cost of segregation project.
Marisa, welcome to Chicago Votes.
I'd love for you to start by framing the issue.
What's actually going on with housing in Chicago now?
[00:58:11] Speaker F: Thanks, Ashley. It's great to be here.
I have found that it sometimes helps to get a little bit of orientation before diving into.
Please
[00:58:21] Speaker B: do
[00:58:22] Speaker F: any stats, Please guide us. Yeah.
So two things I would lay out just in terms of orientation. If you picture a straight line, this is kind of a housing continuum. And all the way to the left would be things like shelters and transitional housing for people experiencing homelessness. And then all the way to the right would be market rate homeownership, market rate rental. Everything that's in between is really what I've spent my career on, which is rental housing and ownership housing that needs a subsidy in order to be affordable to Chicagoans.
And that's the second thing that I want to give a little orientation on, which is what do we mean by affordable?
You mentioned 30% of people's income. A good rule of thumb is that we don't want anyone spending more than a third of their income on their housing.
So if you think about a household that earns $10,000 a month, that means they are looking for housing that costs them about $3,300 a month. And in Chicago, as you note, has been a more affordable city than some $3,300 a month, you can find that in lots of parts of the city. You would have options and choices. Right. If that's, if that's the level you're looking for. But now imagine that your household income is $1,000 a month, and now you're looking for housing that costs you $330 a month and you're not going to Find it, unless you have a subsidy or you find an apartment or a unit that has a subsidy to bring the rent down. So that's really just an orienting factor to think about when we think about housing in general and then affordable housing specifically.
So to get to your what's the state of play in housing question, I want to start just by saying there's really two things nationally that are true that impact Chicago, and that's true everywhere. And then there's a couple things that are very specific to Chicago when it comes to housing. So first national thing I'll just point to is we've been in a major underproduction of housing mode really since the 2008 market crash.
Prior to that point, nationally, we were producing more than 2 million housing units per year. During and post crash, we dropped from 2 million to about 600,000 per year. And we've never really recovered. And the whole housing production industry really downsized accordingly. So it's very hard to just flip a switch and kind of kick back into gear. And then there's been changes that have happened since that have also impacted so rise of Airbnb, demographic changes, a pandemic, inflation, sky high, interest rates now, jump in material costs, tariffs. All of those things have now, you know, that are national phenomenon.
On top of many cities, including Chicago, not updating their zoning code to really allow for more production, all of that combines to make not enough housing being produced at any weather, market rate, or affordable.
And that really has roots in that underproduction that began in 2008. So that's national.
The other national thing is affordable specific, which is that as a country, we don't treat housing you can afford as an entitlement.
An entitlement means something like, let's say, unemployment insurance. It expands and contracts according to the need of whoever needs it. You don't get put on a waiting list if you need this benefit, but when it comes to affordable housing, you do. So as a country, only one in four people who actually qualify for a subsidy actually get it. And so that's a national decision we've made as a country, and it plays out here in China, Chicago. So there's no city in the whole country that has the resources they need to adequately, affordably house people. So that's another just national background to understand.
But then let's add on to that some things that are local Chicago specific that make things harder. And I would say that those two things in my book are aldermanic prerogative and some pretty extreme racial and economic segregation.
So those two things combined to make the affordable housing we do have heavily overrepresented on the south and west sides of the city, and it makes it very hard to get new housing of any type approved.
[01:03:02] Speaker B: That's such a helpful framing to think about it, kind of what's going on with the national side of the housing world and also the Chicago side, because then we could think about kind of the levers to fix it. If you think about, okay, what can we do in our city? And then what do we need to kind of advocate for more nationally? Right. And I know housing data can cut a lot of different ways. We have home prices, rent burden, inventory, vacancy rates. When you're looking at kind of the data, what's the number indicator that you think tells the most honest story about what's going on with housing in Chicago?
[01:03:36] Speaker F: So I'll give you one that's an overall and then one that's specific to affordable housing. And the overall one is that the Chicago metro area, not just the city, but the metro area, is top three nationwide for housing under production. That's not a top three list you want to be on. Right.
That's according to up for Growth. So in actual homes, they calculate we're short about 165,000 homes. You mentioned our rents are increasing faster than New York or la. Also not a list we want to be on.
And there's a lot of research that shows that with more housing, the cost of housing goes down for everyone. So that it really matters that we're not producing more housing.
A big reason indicators really seem to point to our bottleneck on supply is driving prices up. So that's an important factor. On the overall note, a metric on the affordable side, according to the Institute for housing studies at DePaul, we're almost 120,000 units short of the affordable housing that we need in Chicago.
Just to put that in context, when I was housing commissioner, we were funding new and rehabbed affordable units at about 1,200 a year.
We were funding about 1,200 new and rehabbed units a year. If you do the math, it's not good math. It would take us 100 years, and that's only if we lost no currently existing affordable units, which is not a realistic expectation. Right. So the math doesn't work. That stems back to the national lack of prioritization that is then exacerbated by local decisions.
[01:05:24] Speaker B: Yeah, you're really pointing to that kind of supply issue. That's this critical bottleneck to kind of us fixing the problem.
And I know you had mentioned that Chicago has this reputation for being more affordable, but clearly that's shifted. And clearly we've had supply issues. But you also pointed to those supply issues occurring since 2008. So it's been a long time since we've seen these kind of supply issues. Why is this problem coming to a head now like the last five years when we've had kind of issues starting stemming back from 20 years?
[01:05:58] Speaker F: Yeah, I mean, it's not hard to imagine that the longer that you under build, the worse it gets and sometimes in ways that are pretty hard to come back from. So to give one example, if you think about many Chicago neighborhoods were built with two to four flats as, you know, kind of just part of the fabric of the neighborhood. And you might have an owner occupant in one unit and they rent out the other one. Or you might have multiple generations of a family that all live in one three flat, for instance. In many cases, that is, that is older housing. And it's what we would refer to as naturally occurring affordable housing, or noaa.
Basically that by nature of it being older and having been around for a long time, it's going to naturally just be at a more accessible price point point whether to buy or to rent. But since 2013, we lost 25,000 units in two to four flats alone.
So that's a lot of units lost. Yeah. And it's hard to get that kind of gentle density back once you've lost it. Right. If a 3 flat becomes a single family home, you've now lost those units. And there is a fair amount of evidence to show that if we were producing more, it would reduce the pressure on these kinds of conversions.
[01:07:28] Speaker B: Yeah. So it sounds like there's just been a kind of a pressure cooker building and building and building, and now we're just kind of reaping what we sowed.
[01:07:34] Speaker F: Yes.
[01:07:36] Speaker B: And the mayor has real tools on housing. You know, we've got zoning, the Department of Housing, TIF funds, affordable housing mandates. You directed a lot of funding to affordable housing when you were commissioner. But there are also huge forces that the mayor doesn't control. You know, interest rates, construction, state law.
For a voter trying to hold the next mayor accountable, what's actually within the mayor's control and what isn't. So that we know what to kind of listen for on the campaign trail.
[01:08:02] Speaker F: Yeah. I think it's so important to ask this question and to understand it because like I said at the beginning, there is no mayor that has sufficient resources to adequately House people? None. Because that is the choice we've made as a country. So I do think that's an important backdrop. But that being said, there are still a lot of things a mayor can do in the realm of process, in the realm of legislation, in the realm of policy. So let's talk about each. So on the process side, I'm going to take a topic that might kind of make your eyes cross, but it's really important. Let's talk about permitting, for instance.
There's something that I call the time and uncertainty tax that comes to in terms of development in Chicago. And it's a major tax that we impose on developers.
And one of the many ways that shows up is not knowing how long it's going to take you to actually get a permit for the development that you're trying to do.
And I had a couple years ago, I moderated a panel with the mayor of San Diego and is a very unaffordable city. The mayor made a clear mandate to say, we have got to make our processes more just efficient and predictable. And so he did. Two executive orders, 2023 and 2024, to implement new permitting timelines, increase the workforce, assign dedicated project managers.
Now more than 50% of their permits are issued same day.
Affordable housing permits average just nine days. It's pretty remarkable. Wow. And notably, Chicago is working on this with their cut the tape initiative. But there's a really long ways to go, and it's a big factor.
The other thing, on a policy and legislation side of what a mayor can control, that I'll point to, to give one example, Chicago has a Transit Oriented Development Ordinance. It was passed in 2013. We've strengthened it four times. Like, we have made very clear that we believe that land located near transit should be dense. It should have reduced parking, and it should have affordability. We have made that very clear in our legislation.
And yet what has happened repeatedly is that a developer says, got it. I read the legislation.
I understand what you want on this land near transit. Here's my plan to deliver on that. And then we proceed to extract a pound of flesh and relitigate every development on an indeterminate timeline, as if we don't have an entire ordinance spelling out very clearly what our priorities are and what we want. Again, time and uncertainty tax.
And a mayor can, and in my view, should insist on moving these projects forward to a vote.
And under Mayor Lightfoot, we did that where it was a dense development near the Blue line, and with 20% affordable, it was 80% market rate. 20% affordable. We advanced it over the local alders objections and we won.
So a mayor can and in my view should insist on an equitable distribution of affordable housing throughout the city.
Not only where it's cheapest to build and not only where people will protest the least.
[01:11:18] Speaker B: And is that just a housing by housing or development by development change? Like the mayor kind of needs to signal that this is going to happen or is that something that needs to be more legislated?
[01:11:32] Speaker F: I think both.
We did put some legislation in the 2022 connected communities ordinance that mandates that after a certain amount of time, development needs to be brought to a vote.
There are things that you can do to force movement because it used to be that an elder could just put a brick on a deal if they never wanted it to see the light of day. And that did happen.
There are legislative things that you can do, but some of it is practice and deference that can't be mandated. But it can be through relationships and through having a really public North Star where you are saying this is what we're about as a city that I do think you can make change.
[01:12:19] Speaker B: Public pressure. It's often very helpful. Right.
And you're kind of starting to tease out some of the kind of trade offs that need to happen when we're talking about housing and what we define even as affordable housing when the next mayor comes to office, what are those trade offs that he or she will have to to confront?
[01:12:37] Speaker F: Yeah, I'm going to stick to affordable housing in particular with this answer because the trade offs related to that are ones I've spent a lot of time trying to understand better.
And I want to talk about two things which is cost and choice.
So trade off wise, you will find people that will argue that because we have such an under supply of affordable housing and because there are so many people who desperately need it, we should build it as cheaply as possible so that we can really spread those meager resources as the furthest.
One of the most straightforward ways to do this would be to build housing where the land is cheapest on the south and west sides of the city.
While I am sympathetic to that argument because I also want the most affordable housing possible, I just don't agree that that's the answer. And the reason why is that it's a myth that there is a way to affordably house people cheaply.
And the reason is that the math shows up one way or the other. If we think like, hey, we can put affordable housing where the land is cheapest and the rents are lowest. It turns out that segregation is not cheap for anybody in this city or in this region. And we did a study on this, we've talked about this, on what segregation cost Chicago when I was at the Metropolitan Planning Council.
And it's a lot. It's 4.4 billion in lost income, 8 billion in lost regional GDP, 30% more homicides, 83,000 less bachelor's degrees.
So when people say put all the affordable housing where it's cheapest, just remember it's not cheap. It's just that we don't get the bill until later.
And we know this because Chicago started out segregating people who came to Chicago through the great migration in 1914.
So we've been at this 110 plus years now, and we've been paying the bill ever since.
So that's one factor on trade offs. But the second one is actually much, much more important to me, which is about choice.
And I just think people should have choices in where they live, period.
That's what I want in my life. I'm sure that's what you want in your life.
And people who need a subsidy to live affordably, I want them to have just as many options about where they should live as someone who doesn't.
So if you want or need to move because of your job or your child's school or for whatever reason, I want you to have the option to be able to do that. And if you want to stay right where you are and move up the economic ladder where you are, I want you to have options and choices to do that, too.
I want for Chicagoans what sociologist Monica Bell calls residential freedom.
[01:15:41] Speaker B: I love that term. I've never actually heard that, so I'll take that with me.
And you're pointing to so many just hidden costs, both as a city and also personally, that we need to, like, contend with that. You know, we don't. They're not numbers that you're going to see in the short term. They're numbers that you're going to see kind of in the long term and also that affect the lives of everyone here.
Every mural candidate is going to talk about affordable housing. It's in the national sphere, it's in the city sphere.
So what separates in your mind, candidates who have a real plan from those who just have kind of a good talking point. What should I be listening for as a voter?
[01:16:19] Speaker F: Well, I'll be a voter in this next election, too, just like you and everyone else listening. And, you know, I'll say the question that I would like to hear candidates answer on is what would you do about the time and uncertainty tax that Chicago levies on development?
Now, notice I didn't say how are you going to build 120,000 affordable units? Because that's not something in the mayor's control.
But they can do something about both our processes and our policies around housing, and they should have a plan to do that.
[01:16:53] Speaker B: Yeah, I appreciate that. You have to listen to kind of the process and what they're going to do. Not necessarily the kind of campaign headline figure.
[01:17:02] Speaker F: Yeah, I mean, I think what's interesting is that more than at any other point in my lifetime, we're suddenly hearing at a national level. We have national legislation. It was part of the 2024 presidential election. Was actually talking about homeownership and the need for more housing. And the Road to Housing act is in Congress right now. We're actually hearing about housing way more than at any other time in my adult life.
But it's not enough to say we need more, you know, we need more housing. I am really interested in. Right. And how would you do it? Because there are ways to do it and I want to understand how you would tackle it.
[01:17:39] Speaker B: No, I appreciate that.
I want to end with a personal question. So you spent your career at the intersection of policy, city government and community.
In your view, outside of just housing, what does it take to be a good mayor in Chicago?
[01:17:55] Speaker F: So I will say a mayor has to be a mile wide and an inch deep on most things. Right. There's so many topics that come at you in any given day, and based on their particular background or their interest, they might have a real set of expertise on certain things. But the sheer enormity of topics that you have to be conversant on is overwhelming. And at times when I would be part of a press conference with then Mayor Lightfoot and you would do the.
She would get briefed ahead of time on all the topics she was likely to be asked about of the day. And I just remember thinking like, thank goodness I only have to talk about the thing that I spend the most time on and know the most. Right.
It's a. You know, a mayor doesn't have that luxury.
So given that, I think what's crucial is that a mayor is someone who is a really clear on their North Star and their guiding principles. Because when you have impossible decisions to make, which there will be countless, that's what you have to go back to.
B. That they hire smart people who share that orientation and then see that they let them make Decisions that flow from that orientation, not from what will benefit my allies or punish my enemies, which is, I will say on a personal note, something that I don't think Mayor Lightfoot gets credit for, but was actually my experience working with her. She kept a firewall between her alliances or grievances with council and my funding decisions because we were in agreement on the North Star, which goes back to that first principle. Right. If we're in agreement that we should have an equitable distribution of affordable housing across Chicago and we're in agreement that we should prioritize Transit Oriented Development, et cetera, then as long as that was true, then you let the chips fall where they may.
And that was, I think that's a really important orientation. And what I would be, what I would be thinking about as well in any future mayor
[01:20:16] Speaker B: as a voter now. Yes. That you have your vote set for the next election.
Marisa, thank you. I think often people hear housing crisis and assume it's a problem maybe someone else has.
But you've really pointed that it's a problem that, you know, it touches everyone in the city, every neighborhood. It's a personal, national and Chicago problem that we have to think about and tackle with a lot of changes and process.
So it's a really valuable perspective. So thank you.
[01:20:45] Speaker F: Thank you for having me and thanks for this incredible civic education effort.
[01:20:49] Speaker B: Well, thanks for being part of it.
Okay, that's four issues, four experts and a lot to digest.
Let me try to pull out the through line.
What strikes me about every single one of these conversations is how often an honest answer is, it's complicated.
Crime is down, but the burden is not shared equally. The economy has real strengths, but growth isn't reaching its potential or every neighborhood.
Graduation rates are up, but college completion is lagging.
Housing has historically been affordable, but that window is closing fast.
None of these problems have simple solutions. They involve real trade offs, real constraints, and real choices about who gets prioritized.
And that's what governing looks like. It's about prioritization, execution, and making difficult choices.
The next episode is going to go deeper into the city's budget.
Every one of the issues we talked about today runs through the budget. How the city raises money, how it spends it, and how it manages. The gap between the two is going to shape what's even possible for the next mayor.
Then in the following episodes, we'll take these frameworks and apply them directly, hearing from mayoral candidates about how they plan to navigate these realities.
I hope today gave you a sharper framework for what to listen for when the candidates start making their pitches, because the question isn't just whether they have a good talking point, it's whether they have a plan that's honest about the constraints. If this episode was useful to you, please share it with someone in your life who wants to be a more informed Chicago voter. That's exactly who this show is for. We'll see you next time. Vote Chicago 2027 is an independent publication and podcast. This program is not affiliated with, sponsored by, endorsed by, or connected to any political campaign, political party, political action committee, super pac, government agency, or any other organization. Any similarity in name to any other organization is not intended to imply any affiliation, endorsement or connection. This program does not endorse, support, oppose or recommend any candidate for the 2027 mayoral election or any other public office. The publication of a candidate's interview does not constitute an endorsement of that candidate. A candidate's participation does not constitute their endorsement of this program. All declared and qualified candidates for the 2027 Chicago mayoral election have been or will be invited to participate. Participate Interviews are conducted using a standardized format to ensure fairness and equal treatment. If a candidate has not yet appeared, the invitation remains open. The views, opinions, claims and statements expressed by candidates are solely their own. This program does not verify, fact check or vouch for the accuracy, truthfulness or completeness of any candidate's statements. Listeners and readers are encouraged to conduct their own research and consult multiple sources before making voting decisions. This program is produced for informational, educational purposes only. Nothing herein constitutes political advice, legal advice, financial advice, or recommendation to take or refrain from taking any action. The copyright for this program is held by 2026 Chicago Syndico, LLC. All rights reserved. All content, including text, video, audio, graphics and logos, is the property of the producer and is protected by US International copyright laws. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution or use is prohibited without prior written consent to the fullest extent permitted by law. This program, its producers, hosts, employees, agents and affiliates should not be liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, consequential, special or punitive damages arising out of any or related to the use of this website, podcast, or any content therein, including any reliance on statements made by candidates. This disclaimer Any disputes arising from the use of this website or podcast shall be governed by the State of Illinois. Exclusive jurisdiction and venue shall lie in the state or federal courts located in Cook County, Illinois. For more information about voter registration, polling locations and how to participate in the 2027 Chicago mayoral election, please contact the Chicago Board of election
[email protected] for questions, concerns or legal inquiries, please contact votechicagoubstack.com.